Method and apparatus for recycling lithium-ion batteries

ABSTRACT

Cathode material from exhausted lithium ion batteries are dissolved in a solution for extracting the useful elements Co (cobalt), Ni (nickel), Al (Aluminum) and Mn (manganese) to produce active cathode materials for new batteries. The solution includes compounds of desirable materials such as cobalt, nickel, aluminum and manganese dissolved as compounds from the exhausted cathode material of spent cells. Depending on a desired proportion, or ratio, of the desired materials, raw materials are added to the solution to achieve the desired ratio of the commingled compounds for the recycled cathode material for new cells. The desired materials precipitate out of solution without extensive heating or separation of the desired materials into individual compounds or elements. The resulting active cathode material has the predetermined ratio for use in new cells, and avoids high heat typically required to separate the useful elements because the desired materials remain commingled in solution.

RELATED APPLICATIONS

This patent application is a continuation (CON) of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 17/572,079, filed Jan. 10, 2022, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR RECYCLING LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES”, which is a continuation (CON) of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 17/412,742, filed Aug. 26, 2021, entitled “CHARGE MATERIAL FOR RECYCLED LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES,” which is a continuation-in-part (CIP) of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/164,952, filed Oct. 19, 2018, now U.S. Pat. No. 11,127,992, entitled “CHARGE MATERIAL FOR RECYCLED LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES,” which is a continuation in part (CIP) of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/358,862, filed Nov. 22, 2016, now U.S. Pat. No. 10,522,884, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR RECYCLING LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES,” which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/259,161, filed Nov. 24, 2015 entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR RECYCLING LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES” and which is a Continuation-in-Part (CIP) of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/855,994, filed Apr. 3, 2013, now U.S. Pat. No. 9,834,827, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR RECYCLING LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES,” which claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. § 119(e) of U.S. Provisional Patent App. No. 61/620,051, filed Apr. 4, 2012, entitled “FULL CLOSED LOOP FOR RECYCLING LITHIUM ION BATTERIES,” all incorporated herein by reference in entirety.

BACKGROUND

For decades, portable electrical power supplies have taken the form of batteries that release electrical energy from an electrochemical reaction. Various battery chemistries, such as traditional “dry cell” carbon flashlight batteries, and lead acid “wet” cells common in automobiles have provided adequate portable electrical power. Modern electronics, however, place significantly greater demands on the longevity and mass of batteries. Battery power has traditionally come at a premium of the mass required for the charge material for generating sufficient current. Conventional flashlight batteries deliver only low current. Automobile batteries for delivering an intense but brief high amperage flow to a starter motor are very dense and large. Modern electronic devices, such as cell phones, computing devices, and automobiles, demand substantial current delivery while being lightweight and small enough to avoid hindering the portability of the host device.

Rechargeable nickel-cadmium (NiCad) and nickel metal hydride (NiMH) had gained popularity for rechargeable batteries for portable devices. Recently, however, advances in lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) have been significant such that they have become the most popular power source for portable electronics equipment, and are also growing in popularity for military, electric vehicle, and aerospace applications. Continuing development of personnel electronics, hybrid and electric vehicles, ensures that Li-ion batteries will continue to be increasingly in demand.

SUMMARY

Exhausted LIBs undergo a physical separation process for removing solid battery components, such as casing and plastics, and electrodes are dissolved in a solution for extracting the useful elements Co (cobalt), Ni (nickel), Mn (manganese), and Li (lithium), from mixed cathode materials and utilizing the recycled elements to produce active materials for new batteries. Configurations herein are based, in part, on the observation that conventional approaches do not recycle and recover Li-ion batteries with LiNiCoAlO₂, which is being used in automobile application (for example Tesla™ electric vehicles).

The solution includes compounds of desirable materials such as cobalt, nickel and manganese dissolved as compounds from the exhausted cathode material of spent cells. Depending on a desired proportion, or ratio, of the desired materials, raw materials are added to the solution to achieve the desired ratio of the commingled compounds for the recycled cathode material for new cells. A strong base, such as sodium hydroxide, raises the pH such that the desired materials precipitate out of solution without extensive heating or separation of the desired materials into individual compounds or elements. The resulting active cathode material has the predetermined ratio for use in new cells, and avoids high heat typically required to separate the useful elements because the desired materials remain commingled in solution and undergo only a change in concentration (ratio) by adding small amounts of pure charge material to achieve a target composition.

Lithium-ion batteries, like their NiCd (nickel-cadmium) and NiMH (nickel-metal hydride) predecessors, have a finite number of charge cycles. It is therefore expected that LIB s will become a significant component of the solid waste stream, as numerous electric vehicles reach the end of their lifespan. Recycling of the charge material in the lithium batteries both reduces waste volume and yields active charge material for new batteries.

Recycling can dramatically reduce the required lithium amount. Various chemicals in lithium ion batteries include valuable metals such as cobalt, manganese, and nickel. Additionally, battery disposal would require that fresh metals be mined for cathode material, and mining has a much bigger environmental impact and cost than simple recycling would. In short, recycling of lithium ion batteries not only protects the environment and saves energy, but also presents a lucrative outlet for battery manufacturers by providing an inexpensive supply of active cathode material for new batteries.

Current recycling procedures for Li-ion cells are generally focused on LiCoO₂ cathode materials. Although some posted their methods to recycle more kinds of cathode materials, all are complex and not necessarily economical or practical. A simple methodology with high efficiency is proposed in order to recycle Li-ion batteries economically and with industrial viability. The disclosed approach results in synthesis of cathode materials (particularly valuable in Li-ion batteries) from recycled components. In contrast to conventional approaches, the disclosed approach does not separate Ni, Mn, and Co out. Instead, uniform-phase precipitation is employed as starting materials to synthesize the cathode materials as active charge material suitable for new batteries. The analytical results showed that the recycling process is practical and has high recovery efficiency, and has commercial value as well.

Configurations herein are based, in part, on the observation that the increasing popularity of lithium ion cells as a source of portable electric power will result in a corresponding increase in spent lithium-based cathode material as the deployed cells reach the end of their useful lifetime. While 97% of lead acid batteries are recycled, such that over 50 percent of the lead supply comes from recycled batteries, lithium ion batteries are not yet being recycled widely. While the projected increase of lithium demand is substantial, analysis of Lithium's geological resource base shows that there is insufficient lithium available in the Earth's crust to sustain electric vehicle manufacture in the volumes required, based solely on Li-ion batteries. Recycling can dramatically reduce the required lithium amount. A recycling infrastructure will ease concerns that the adoption of vehicles that use lithium-ion batteries could lead to a shortage of lithium carbonate and a dependence on countries rich in the supply of global lithium reserves.

Unfortunately, conventional approaches to the above approaches suffer from the shortcoming that recycling approaches include high temperature processes to separate the compounds of the desirable materials of cobalt, manganese, nickel and lithium. This high-temperature process results in breaking down the compounds for separation, but only to recombine them again for new active material. The high temperature approach therefore requires substantial energy, expense, and processing for separating and recombining the desirable materials.

Accordingly, configurations herein substantially overcome the described shortcoming of heat intensive component separation described above by generating a low temperature solution of the desired compounds that is mixed with small amounts of additional pure forms of the desirable materials to achieve a target ratio of the desired active charge materials. The desirable materials are extracted by precipitation to result in recycled active cathode material without separating or breaking down the compounds, allowing a lower temperature and less expensive process to generate the active cathode materials.

The solution includes recovering active materials from lithium ion batteries with LiNiCoAlO₂ chemistry in a manner that can be used to make new active materials for new lithium ion batteries. To date, conventional approaches cannot recover transition metals from LiNiCoAlO₂ in such a form that they can be used to make new cathode materials for LNiCoO₂ or LiNiCoAlO₂ batteries without using expensive organic reagents. The recovered precursor material NiCoAl(OH)₂ or NiCo(OH)₂ can be used for making new LiNiCoAlO₂ or LiNiCoO₂ cathode materials. This may include adding Al(OH)₃ to the precipitated material and/or Ni, Co, or Al sulfates to the solution prior to precipitation.

In the proposed approach, it is desirable that the batteries be of a single stream chemistry (LiNiCoAlO₂) however if there are other chemistries present in the LiMO₂ (where M is manganese, as well as Ni, Al and Co), the manganese can be removed from solution. Ni, Co and Al can be used to precipitate precursor and synthesize cathode materials.

The claimed approach, outlined in more detail below, defines a method of recycling Li ion batteries including generating a solution of aggregate battery materials from spent cells, and precipitating impurities from the generated solution to result in a charge material precursor. Materials are added to adjust the solution to achieve a predetermined ratio of desirable materials based on desired chemistry of the new, recycled battery. Lithium carbonate is introduced and sintered to form cathode materials in the form of LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O₂. Adjusting the desirable materials includes the addition of at least one of Ni, Co or Al, and typically the addition of desirable materials is in the form of salts or ions. A reductant may be employed to maintain an oxidation state of the charge material ions in solution, and impurities may be removed by balancing of pH, oxidation state, and electrodeposition for removal of collateral remnants from the recycling stream such as aluminum and copper current collectors, magnesium and iron from physical casing and conductor materials.

In the approach disclosed below, a method of recycling Li-ion batteries therefore includes generating a solution of aggregate battery materials from spent cells, and precipitating mixtures from the generated solution. A recycler apparatus adjusts the solution to achieve a predetermined ratio of desirable materials, and precipitating the desirable material in the predetermined ratio to form cathode material for a new battery having the predetermined ratio of the desirable materials. It should be noted that although the methods and apparatus disclosed herein employ Li-ion batteries as an example, the principles are intended as illustrative and could be applied to other types of cathode materials suited to other battery chemistries.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The foregoing and other features will be apparent from the following description of particular embodiments disclosed herein, as illustrated in the accompanying drawings in which like reference characters refer to the same parts throughout the different views. The drawings are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon illustrating the principles of the invention.

FIG. 1 is a context diagram of a battery recycling environment suitable for use with configurations herein;

FIG. 2 is a flowchart of lithium battery recycling in the environment of FIG. 1 ;

FIG. 3 is a diagram of charge flow (electrons) during charging and discharging of the batteries of FIG. 1 ;

FIG. 4 is a diagram of battery structure of the batteries of FIG. 1 ;

FIG. 5 is a diagram of recycling the cathode material in the battery of FIG. 4 ;

FIG. 6 is a process flow diagram of recycling lithium-aluminum ion batteries;

FIG. 7 is a process flow for an alternate configuration of recycling lithium-aluminum batteries using aluminum hydroxide;

FIG. 8 is a process flow diagram for a combined recycling process for both Ni/Mn/Co (NMC) and Ni/Co/Al (NCA) batteries for any suitable molar ratio; and

FIG. 9 is a Pourbaix diagram Electrodeposition of Cu as used for impurity removal in the process of FIG. 8 .

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Depicted below is an example method and apparatus for recycling batteries such as lithium ion batteries. The proposed approach is an example and is applicable to other lithium and non-lithium batteries for recycling spent batteries and recovering active cathode material suitable for use in new batteries. FIG. 1 is a context diagram of a battery recycling environment 100 suitable for use with configurations herein. Referring to FIG. 1 , in the battery recycling environment 100, electronic devices 110 such as laptops, automobiles (hybrid and pure electric), computers, smartphones, and any other type of battery supported equipment is suitable for use with the disclosed approach. The electronic devices contribute spent cells 120, having exhausted cathode material 122 that nonetheless includes the raw materials responsive to the recycling approach discussed herein. A physical separation process 124 dismantles the battery to form a granular mass 126 of the exhausted battery material including the raw materials in particulate form, usually by simply crushing and grinding the spent battery casings and cells therein.

Physical separation is applied to remove the battery cases (plastic) and electrode materials, often via magnetic separation that draws out the magnetic steel. A recycler 130 includes physical containment of a solution 141 including the remaining granular mass 126 from the spent charge materials, typically taking the form of a powder from the agitated (crushed) spent batteries. Additional raw materials 142 are added to achieve a predetermined ratio of the desirable materials in the solution 141. Following the recycling process, as discussed further below, active charge materials 134 result and are employed to form new cells 140 including the recycled cathode material 132. The new cells 140 may then be employed in the various types of devices 110 that contributed the exhausted, spent cells 120. The recycler may include an apparatus for containing the solution 141 such that a pH adjuster or modifier and raw materials may be added to the solution 141.

FIG. 2 is a flowchart of lithium battery recycling in the environment of FIG. 1 . Referring to FIGS. 1 and 2 , the method of recycling cathode material 122 as disclosed herein includes generating a solution 141 from cathode materials derived from exhausted battery cells 120, as depicted at step 200. The method combines additional raw material 142 to achieve a predetermined ratio of the materials in solution 141, and is such that the solution temperature is maintained sufficiently low for avoiding high temperature process common in conventional recycling approaches. The solution 141 precipitates the precursor materials 134 by increasing the pH of the solution 141, such that the precipitated materials 134 have the predetermined ratio and having suitable proportion for use to synthesize the cathode material 132 for the new battery cells 140. In the example configuration, the desirable materials include manganese (Mn), cobalt (Co), and nickel (Ni) extracted from cathode material of battery cells. In the solution 141, the desirable materials remaining commingled during precipitation such that the resulting cathode material 134 has the correct proportion for usage in the new cells 140.

FIG. 3 is a diagram of charge flow (electrons) during charging and discharging of the batteries of FIG. 1 . Batteries in general produce an electron flow via an electrochemical reaction that causes an electrical current from the electron flow to provide the electrical power, coupled with a corresponding flow of ions in the battery between an anode and cathode. Referring to FIGS. 1 and 3 , a lithium-ion battery (LIB) 140′ generates a negative electron flow 150 to power an electrical load 152 in a reversible manner (for recharge), similar to other rechargeable batteries. During charging, a charger 170 provides a voltage source that causes the electron flow 151′ to reverse. Lithium ions 154 move from the negative electrode 160 to the positive electrode 162 during discharge, and back when charging. An anode tab 161 electrically connects the negative electrodes 160 for connection to the load 152/charger 170, and a cathode tab 163 connects the positive electrodes 162. An electrolyte 168 surrounds the electrodes for facilitating ion 154 transfer. A separator prevents contact between the anode 160 and cathode 162 to allow ionic transfer via the electrolyte 168 so that the anode and cathode plates do not “short out” from contact. The positive electrode 162 half-reaction (cathode reaction), take LiCoO2 as an example: LiCoO₂

Li_(1-x)CoO₂ +xLi+xe ⁻ The negative electrode 160 half-reaction is: xLi⁺ +xe ⁻+6C

Li_(x)C₆ Overall cell reaction: C+LiCoO₂

Li_(x)C+Li_(1-x)CoO₂ During charging, the transition metal cobalt is oxidized from Co³⁺ to Co⁴⁺, and reduced from Co⁴⁺ to Co³⁺ during discharge.

FIG. 4 is a diagram of battery structure of FIG. 1 . Referring to FIGS. 3 and 4 , the physical structure of the cell 140 is a cylinder encapsulation of rolled sheets defining the negative electrode 160 and the positive electrode 162.

Primary functional parts of the lithium-ion battery 140 are the anode 160, cathode, 162 electrolyte 168, and separator 172. LIBs use an intercalated lithium compound as the electrode materials. The most commercially popular anode 160 (negative) electrode material contains graphite, carbon and PVDF (polyvinylidene fluoride) binder, coated on copper foil. The cathode 162 (positive) electrode contains cathode material, carbon, and PVDF binder, coated on aluminum foil. The cathode 162 material is generally one of three kinds of materials: a layered oxide (such as lithium cobalt or nickel oxide), a polyanion (such as lithium iron phosphate), or a spinel (such as lithium manganese oxide), and defines the cathode material 122 and recycled cathode material 132 as disclosed herein. Alternatively, the disclosed approach for recycling cathode material may be applied to other materials in various battery components, such as anodic and electrolyte components. The electrolyte 168 is typically a mixture of organic carbonates, generally use non-coordinating anion salts such as lithium hexafluorophosphate (LiPF₆). The electrolyte 168 acts as an ionic path between electrodes. The outside metal casing defines the negative terminal 161′, coupled to the anode tab 161, and the top cap 163′ connects to the cathode tab 163. A gasket 174 and bottom insulator 176 maintains electrical separation between the polarized components.

Conventional approaches for recycling focus on LiCoO₂ in spent LIBs. However, with the development of lithium ion battery technologies, different cathode materials are now being used to produce lithium ion batteries such as LiCoO₂, LiFePO4, LiMnO₂, LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O₂ and LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O₂. It can be complex to sort out lithium ion batteries based on the battery chemistry and conventional methods cannot effectively recycle lithium ion batteries with mixed chemistries because different procedures are required to separate the respective compounds for reuse as active cathode material.

The cathode materials widely used in commercial lithium ion batteries include LiCoO₂, LiMn₂O₄, LiNiO₂, LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O₂, LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O₂ and LiFePO₄. In order to recycle lithium ion batteries effectively, it is beneficial to consider all the various battery chemistries. Thus, it is beneficial to develop a simpler and environmentally acceptable recycling process generally applicable to various widely used LIBs used widely. Configurations disclosed herein present an example to extract compounds including the desirable elements of Co, Ni, Mn, and Li from mixed cathode materials and utilize the recycled materials to produce active materials for batteries. Alternate chemistries may be recycled using the methods disclosed.

FIG. 5 is a diagram of recycling the cathode material in the battery of FIG. 4 . Referring to FIGS. 1, 4 and 5 , at step 1 discharged Li ion batteries 120 are crushed/shredded. Mechanical separation processes are applied as a pretreatment to separate the outer cases and shells and the plastic fraction, as shown at step 1a.

The sieved cathode powder will be leached by 4-5M sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄) and 29-32% hydrogen peroxide for about 2-3 hours at 70-80° C., as depicted at step 2. Other concentrations of sulfuric acid may also be employed. Addition of hydrogen peroxide H₂O₂ changes not only Fe2+ to Fe3+, but also other metal ions Mn, Ni, Co to 2+, thus leading to separate iron by controlling pH of the solution in step 3. After filtration, residual LiFeO4 and carbon can be separated by centrifugation, as shown at step 2a. Other impurities are also removed from the surface of the solution, as shown at step 2b.

The metallic elements of interest are transfer to the aqueous solution as the crushed raw cathode materials form a granular mass 126 used to generate the solution of aggregate battery materials from the spent cells, as depicted at step 3. This includes the desirable materials of Co (cobalt), Ni (nickel), Mn (manganese), and Li (lithium in the example shown; other desirable materials may be employed using the present approach with alternate battery chemistries. The pH is adjusted to extract iron, copper and aluminum as Fe(OH)₃, Cu(OH)₂ and Al(OH)₃. This involves adjusting the pH to a range between 3.0-7.0. Accordingly, NaOH solution is added to adjust pH number to deposit Fe(OH)₃, Cu(OH)2 and Al(OH)₃ which have a lower solubility constant, and keep Mn²⁺, Co²⁺, Ni²⁺ in the solution, then Fe(OH)₃, Cu(OH)₂ and Al(OH)3 are separated by filtration. It should be noted that the above processes include maintaining the solution 141 at a temperature between 40 deg. C. and 80 deg. C., thus avoiding high heat required in conventional approaches.

The pH adjustment for impurity removal generally adjusts the pH based on particular impurities sought for removal. A pH range of around 3-5, for example, causes iron to precipitate out of solution. Copper tends to precipitate at a pH around 5-7. Depending on the quantity and type of impurities in the recycling stream, the impurity removal phase may target different pH ranges. Once the charge material metals (Ni, Mn, Co) have been dissolved, the pH will have been reduced to around 1-3 depending on the quantity and concentration of the acid leach. Before the pH is raised to precipitate the NMC in a pure form, impurities can be precipitated, optionally through addition of a reductant, discussed further below. In other words, while adding sodium hydroxide or other strong base for raising the pH, the impurities precipitate out at a lower pH, followed by precipitation of NMC hydroxides at a higher pH.

The desirable materials are now dissolved in the solution 141. Based on the predetermined target ratio of the desirable materials, the solution is adjusted to achieve the predetermined ratio of desirable materials. In the example approach, this is a 1:1:1 combination of cobalt, manganese and nickel, although any suitable ratio could be employed. Therefore, adjusting the solution includes identifying a desired ratio of the desirable materials for use in recycled cathode material resulting from the generated solution 141, and adding raw materials 142 to achieve the desired ratio, such that the raw materials include additional quantities of the desirable materials and subsequently adding the new raw materials to attain the predetermined ratio. Adding the raw materials includes adding additional quantities of the desirable materials for achieving the desired ratio without separating the individual desirable materials already in solution form, therefore the mixed desirable materials (Co, Mn, Ni) do not need to be separately drawn or extracted as in conventional approaches, which usually involve high heat to break the molecular bonds of the compounds. Furthermore, in an alternate configuration, selected metallic elements can be separated from the solution, which can be used to synthesize particular cathode materials. Therefore, the pH may be adjusted to extract one or more metal ions or other elements prior to adjusting the solution for the predetermined ratio of desirable materials, and subsequent extract the remaining desirable materials in the predetermined ratio.

Rather, the concentration of Mn²⁺, Co²⁺, Ni²⁺ in the solution is tested, and adjusted the ratio of them to 1:1:1 or other suitable ratio with additional CoSO₄, NiSO₄, MnSO₄. NaOH solution is added to increase the pH to around 11, usually within a range of 10.0-13, thus adjusting a pH of the solution such that the desirable materials for the new (recycled) charge materials precipitate. Ni_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)(OH)₂ or Ni_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)O(OH) or a mixture thereof can be coprecipitated such that the respective mole ratio is 1:1:1, as depicted at step 4. Ni_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)(OH)2 or Ni_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O(OH) or a mixture with different ratios of x, y, and z can also be precipitated. Na₂CO₃ is added in the solution to deposit Li₂CO₃, as depicted at step 5. Finally, the recovered Ni_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)(OH)₂ and Li₂CO₃ are sintered to produce the cathode material.

In the example arrangement, the desirable materials include manganese (Mn), cobalt (Co), and nickel (Ni) extracted from charge material 122 of the spent battery cells 120, in which the desirable materials remain commingled in the solution 141 during precipitation. Adjusting the pH includes adding a substance, such as NaOH (sodium hydroxide, also referred to as lye or caustic soda) for raising the pH such that the desirable materials precipitate, however any suitable substance for raising the pH may be employed. The end result is that adjusting the pH includes adding sodium hydroxide for raising the pH to permit precipitation of the desirable materials for use as cathode precursor material without separately precipitating the individual compounds defining the desirable materials. The precipitation of the desirable materials occurs at temperatures below 80 deg. C., avoiding high heat required in conventional approaches. It should be further noted that, in contrast to conventional approaches, the desirable materials remain commingled during precipitation as a combined hydroxide (OH), (OH)₂ or carbonate (CO₃). The addition of the additional charge materials for adjusting the ratio achieves the desired molar ratio for the resulting recycled battery. The intermediate, or precursor form will result in a lithium oxide form following sintering with lithium carbonate Li₂CO₃.

Na₂CO₃ is added in the solution to deposit Li₂CO₃ at about 40° C. After filtrating, Li₂CO₃ can be recycled as the starting material to synthesis the active cathode material LiNi_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)O₂, as shown at steps 5 and 5a. Therefore, the method adds back the lithium to the precipitated desirable materials to form active cathode material suitable for the new battery, and precipitates the desirable material in the predetermined ratio to form charge material for a new battery 140 having the predetermined ratio of the desirable materials.

The coprecipitated materials Ni_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)(OH)₂ or Ni_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)O(OH) or their mixture and recovered Li₂CO₃, with additional Li₂CO₃ in molar ratio 1.1 of Li versus M (M═Ni_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)), are mixed and grinded in mortar, as depicted at step 6. The mixture may be reformulated by any suitable processing to form the active cathode material 134 for new batteries 140. In the example approach, the mixture was sintered at 900 for 15 hours. The reaction product may be ground into powder for subsequent distribution and reformation into new cells 140. The LiNi_(1/3)Mn_(1/3)Co_(1/3)O₂ is sintered by a high temperature solid-state method at 900° C. for 15 hours.

Battery chemistries including aluminum (Al) are becoming popular for applications such as electric vehicles, using chemistry such as LiNiCoAlO₂. Conventional approaches for recovering active materials from lithium ion batteries with chemistry LiNiCoAlO₂ in a manner that can be used to make new active materials for new lithium ion batteries have been met with several shortcomings. Conventional processes cannot recover transition metals from LiNiCoAlO₂ in such a form that they can be used to make new cathode materials for LNiCoO₂ or LiNiCoAlO₂ batteries without using expensive organic reagents. The recovered precursor material NiCoAl(OH)₂ or NiCo(OH)₂ can be used for making new LiNiCoAlO₂ or LiNiCoO₂ cathode materials. This may include adding Al(OH)₃ to the precipitated material and/or Ni, Co, or Al sulfates to the solution prior to precipitation. One specific example is that solution of nickel and cobalt sulfates was from recycled material. Al₂(SO₄)₃·18H₂O as Al starting material was dissolved in distilled water. Subsequently, chelating agent 5-sulfosalicylic acid was dissolved in the solution of aluminum sulfates. Solutions of transition metal sulfates, aluminum sulfate, ammonia, and NaOH were pumped into a continuous stirred tank reactor. Total concentration of solutions of the metal sulfates was 1.5 M or other concentrations. Concentration of the chelating agent is 0.05M-0.5M. pH was controlled 10-pH. Stirring speed was 500-1000 rpm and the temperature was controlled in 30-60° C. After the reaction, NiCoAl(OH)2 co-precipitate was filtered, washed and dried. The metal hydroxide co-precipitate precursor was mixed with 5% excess lithium carbonate thoroughly. The mixture was at first calcined at 450° C. for 4-6 h in air, and then sintered at 750-850° C. for 15-20 h in an oxygen atmosphere or air to obtain LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O2 powder to form charge material suitable for use in new batteries.

For such a recycling operation, it is desirable that the batteries be of a single stream chemistry (LiNiCoAlO₂) however if there are other chemistries present in the LiMO₂ (where M is manganese, as well as Ni, Al and Co), the manganese can be removed from solution. Ni, Co and Al can be used to precipitate precursor and synthesize cathode materials.

For the recovery and synthesis of LiNiCoAlO₂ there are at least two approaches. FIG. 6 is a process flow diagram of recycling lithium ion batteries. FIG. 7 is a process flow for an alternate configuration of recycling lithium ion batteries using aluminum hydroxide.

Referring to FIG. 6 , in order to undergo the recovery process, the cathode powders must be separated from the batteries/current collectors. Physical agitation of spent cell materials is used to extract cathode material by leaching crushed spent battery materials in a sealed system or containment to separate current collectors in a solution, as depicted at step 601. An example method of how this could be done is by shredding and sizing. Then the powders can be leached into solution using a combination of sulfuric acid and hydrogen peroxide, thus leaching may include forming a solution from addition of at least one of hydrogen peroxide and sulfuric acid. Impurities can be removed by adjusting a pH of the solution for removing impurities by precipitating hydroxides and filtering. This may be performed by increasing the pH to 5-7, precipitating the respective hydroxides and filtering, as disclosed at step 602. Aluminum hydroxide may also be removed in this step. At step 603, Mn ions in the solution can also be removed by adding suitable chemicals. The concentration of ions in solution will be measured and adjusted to the desired ratio based on the industrial needs. This includes adding at least one of Ni, Co and aluminum salts based on a desired composition of resulting recovered charge materials, as depicted at step 604. It may be desirable to increase the pH above 7 prior to adding Al(SO₄)₃ or Al(OH)₃ or other aluminum salts to the solution. Precursor materials may then be recovered by precipitating using at least one of sodium hydroxide or potassium hydroxide, as shown at step 605. Sintering the recovered precursor materials with lithium carbonate forms active cathode material, as depicted at steps 606 and 607. The precipitate from step 605 can be sold to material or battery manufacturers or can then be mixed and sintered with the lithium carbonate to form active LiNiCoAlO₂.

In an alternate configuration, depicted in FIG. 7 , no aluminum is added to solution and Al(OH)₃ is added to the material after precipitation, after mixing it is sintered with lithium carbonate to form the active material. Therefore, referring to FIG. 7 , steps 701-703 proceed as their counterparts in FIG. 6 . If it is desirable to recover LiNiCoO₂ material the procedure follows FIG. 6 but no aluminum is added back into the solution or precipitate. Accordingly, the process includes adding only Ni or Co prior to precipitating the recovered charge materials at step 704. The process defers addition of aluminum hydroxide (step 706) until after precipitation (step 705) and before sintering at step 708. In general, using the processes depicted in FIGS. 6 and 7 , active charge material formed includes LiNixCoxAlzO2 where x, y and z are integers defining the composition of the resulting active charge material. Other materials including Cu, Al, steel, carbon, lithium carbonate, and other materials including transition metals can also be recovered

In an alternate arrangement, the above approaches converge to a single stream recycling process including both Ni/Mn/Co (NMC) and Ni/Co/Al (NCA) chemistries, by recognizing the common aspects of pH changes and recombining pure (virgin) cathode materials to form a combined precursor having a molar ratio based on the chemistry requirements for the new, recycled cathode materials.

FIG. 8 is a process flow diagram for a combined recycling process for both Ni/Mn/Co and Ni/Co/Al batteries for any suitable molar ratio. In the approach of FIG. 8 , the following benefits are achieved:

1. Both LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O₂ and LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O₂ are cathode materials for Li-ion batteries. These cathode materials can be synthesized in the recycling process. These recovered cathode materials have similar performance with the virgin materials and can be used to make new batteries.

2. In the flow chart of FIG. 8 , both LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O₂ with different ratio of Ni, Mn and Co, and LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O₂ with different ratio of Ni, Co and Al are recovered. LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O₂ and LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O₂ can be synthesized by sintering their carbonates or hydroxides with Li₂CO₃. In our previous patent, LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O₂ is synthesized by sintering Ni_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)(OH)₂ and Li₂CO₃. It should be noted that both the elemental composition (e.g. NMC or NCA) and the molar ratio of those elements are determined both by the molar ratios following leaching, and the addition of pure raw materials to the leached solution, designated by the subscripts x,y,z specifying the respective molar ratios. Other suitable battery chemistries may be formed using the disclosed approach.

3. Based on the recycling stream, LiNi_(x)Mn_(y)Co_(z)O2 or LiNi_(x)Co_(y)Al_(z)O2 can be synthesized. If the recycling stream includes Mn based batteries or Mn compound is added, LiNixMnyCozO2 is synthesized. If the recycling stream does not include Mn based batteries or Mn is removed, LiNixCoyAlzO2 is synthesized.

4. For both LiNixMnyCozO2 and LiNixCoyAlzO2, impurities can be removed by increasing the pH to 5-7, precipitating their hydroxides and filtering.

5. The carbonate and hydroxide precursor precipitates can be obtained by controlling their solubility in the solution.

In FIG. 8 , the processing of the recycling stream for generating new charge material for the recycled battery is shown. The method for recycling lithium-ion batteries, comprising includes, at step 801, receiving a recycling stream of expended, discarded and/or spent lithium ion batteries, and agitating the batteries to expose the internal components and charge material by physical crushing, shredding and/or disengagement to provide surface area open to liquid exposure, as depicted at step 802.

Physical sieving and filtering remove casing, separators and large extraneous materials at step 803, and an acid leaching process commenced at step 804. A leached solution is formed by combining crushed battery material from the lithium battery recycling stream with an acidic leach agent and hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) to separate cathode materials from undissolved material, as depicted at step 804. A low pH solvent bath, leach liquor or other suitable combination immerses the agitated materials of the recycling stream for dissolving the cathode materials such as Ni, Mn, Co and Al. The acidic leach agent may be concentration of sulfuric acid in the range of 2-7 M (molar), and in a particular arrangement, the acidic leach agent is 4M sulfuric acid.

A particular feature of the disclosed approach is adaptability to various target chemistries for the recycled batteries, and sourced from various unknown chemistries in the recycling stream. Design or demand specifications determine material parameters for a recycled battery by identifying a molar ratio and elements of cathode materials corresponding to a charge material chemistry of a recycled battery. Battery usage as directed by a customer, for example, may be an overriding factor, such as automotive electric or hybrid vehicle usage, portable electronic devices, etc. The identified battery chemistry, specifying particular elements and molar ratios, results in the specific electrical characteristics of the recycled batteries produced by the disclosed approach.

Following dissolution in the leach solution, a test or sample is employed to determine a composition of the leach solution by identifying a molar ratio of the ions dissolved therein, thus clarifying the previously unknown collective composition of the input recycling stream. Recall that all charge material has remained comingled in the leach solution-extraction or precipitation of individual elements has not been required.

Based on the determined composition, Ni, Co, Mn or Al salts in a sulfate (xSO₄) or hydroxide (xOH) form are added to the leach solution to adjust the molar ratio of the dissolved cathode material salts in the leach solution to correspond to the identified molar ratio for the recycled battery. Depending on the expected battery chemistry, for example, a NMC chemistry with 1:1:1 ratio may be sought, or alternatively, a NCA chemistry with 1:2:1. Any suitable ratio and combination of charge materials may be selected. One particular selection may be the determination of whether manganese (Mn) is included or whether NCA manganese-free formulation will be employed.

Prior to adjusting the molar ratio, impurities may be precipitated from the leach solution by adding sodium hydroxide until the pH is in a range between 5.0-7.0 for precipitating hydroxide forms of the impurities outside the determined material parameters, as depicted at step 805.

The determined battery chemistry and source recycling stream results in a decision point from step 805. If the chemistry for the recycled battery include manganese (Mn), then the cathode material salts include Ni, Mn and Co in a hydroxide form, as depicted at step 806. Otherwise, if the recycled battery is devoid of Mn, then the cathode material salts include Ni, Co and Al in a hydroxide form, as shown at step 809. In the non-Mn formulation, prior to adding raw material for adjusting the molar ratio, manganese ions may be removed from the leach solution.

Following the branch at step 805, in general, sodium hydroxide is added for raising the pH of the leach solution to at least 10 for precipitating and filtering metal ions of the cathode materials to form a charge material precursor by coprecipitating the Ni, Co, Mn and Al salts remaining in the leach solution as a combined hydroxide (OH), (OH)₂ or carbonate (CO₃) having a molar ratio corresponding to the identified molar ratio for the recycled battery, the charge precursor material responsive to sintering for forming active cathode materials in an oxide form following sintering with lithium carbonate (Li₂CO₃).

In either step, charge precursor material is generated by raising the pH to a range of 10-13.0 for precipitating hydroxide charge material, and more specifically, may include raising pH by adding sodium hydroxide to increase the pH to 11.0, as depicted at steps 807 and 810. The resulting charge material precursor has the form NixMnyCoz(OH)2, NixMnyCozCO3, NixCoyAlz(OH)2 or NixCoyAlzCO3 where the molar ratios defined by x, y, and z are based on the determined material parameters of the recycled battery, as depicted at steps 808 and 811.

In a more general sense, the aluminum sulfate is mixed with a chelating agent, and the aluminum sulfate solution and nickel cobalt sulfate solutions are added with ammonium water and sodium hydroxide to a reactor. A pH monitor constantly monitors and releases additional sodium hydroxide to maintain the pH at 10.0 or other suitable pH to result in coprecipitation of the NCA precursor.

The generalized process of FIG. 8 is intended to accommodate Al based battery chemistries without Mn, but may also be used for any suitable formulation by modifying the molar ratios at steps 806 or 809, as applicable.

The charge material precursor disclosed above results in an active cathode material having improved characteristics. Particles and powders, derived from the recycling stream, include surface ions that enhance pore formation and cumulative pore volume in the resulting active cathode material.

In the recycling stream, physical agitation such as crushing and shredding results in a heterogenous mass of battery materials. The battery materials include not only the exhausted, spent charge material, but the physical casings, electrodes, and current collector components, along with related conduction surfaces, connectors, wires and the like which were part of the battery product deposited in the recycling stream. Physical separation of extraneous battery parts has limitations, and a resulting powder or granular mass inevitably contains a small amount of impurities such as ferrous metals, copper, and other materials. Typically, this quantity of impurities is less than 2%.

Further, the exhausted charge material exhibits ions on the particle surface that differ from newly refined, virgin materials that conventional approaches employ. Conventional approached employ newly refined particulate forms of materials such as Ni, Mn, Co and Al, and form active charge material using exclusively virgin materials. In contrast, the claimed approach employs particulate forms from the recycling stream, and then supplements as needed with virgin materials. Residual surface ions in the recycled materials provide an ionic presence that facilitates pore formation for increasing the cumulative pore volume. The pore volume allows electrolyte to contact a greater surface area and propagate more readily around the charge material for facilitating higher discharge rates.

Performance and manufacturing ability of Lithium-Ion batteries (LIB s) are affected by the choice of materials used within the battery. The ability to control the pore size and shape, particle size and shape, surface area and density of electrode materials is significant in the optimization of LIB performance. LIB performance is characterized by energy storage, also known as capacity, and current delivery, also known as loading or power. Energy and power characteristics are defined by particle size on the electrodes. Larger particles increase the surface area for maximum capacity and fine material decreases it for high power.

A high surface area reduces the diffusion distance within electrodes and helps to facilitate ion exchange between the electrode and the electrolyte, improving the efficiency of the electrochemical reactions. In configurations herein, ions already in the recycled materials lead to an increased pore volume over virgin materials. Ions in the surface of the powder or particles lead to an increased pore volume in the resulting active charge material.

Conversely, decreasing particle size lowers the presence of electrolyte that fills the voids. The volume of electrolyte within the cell determines battery capacity. Decreasing the particle size reduces the voids between the particles, thereby lowering the electrolyte content. Too little electrolyte reduces ionic mobility and affects performance

In configurations disclosed herein, an ability to move charge quickly and hence, high discharge rates, are preferred over battery longevity. In typical industry standards, charge and discharge rates of a battery are governed by C-rates. The capacity of a battery is commonly rated at 1 C, meaning that a fully charged battery rated at 1 Ah should provide 1 A for one hour. The C-rate therefore describes discharge rate relative to a 1 amp per hour per battery amp/hour capacity.

The disclosed active cathode material for a lithium-ion battery encompasses a charge material precursor resulting from a recycling stream of crushed disposed batteries. The charge material precursor has a ratio of charge materials based on a recycled battery chemistry and impurities resulting from the recycling stream, As discussed above, the recycled battery chemistry defines an intended molar ratio of elements in a resulting recycled battery, including a small (typically less than 2%) of impurities which remain. Impurities typically include Al, Cu and Fe.

The charge material precursor further incorporates virgin stock of elemental compounds added to meet the ratio of charge materials. The virgin stock includes new elemental compounds based on a virgin form of refined elements corresponding to the charge materials. This added virgin stock adjusts the charge material percentages based on this intended molar ratio for the finished, recycled battery product. The charge material precursor results from coprecipitation of a combined solution of the charge materials from both the recycling stream and the virgin stock based on additions of the elemental compounds to achieve the ratio of charge materials. Any amount of virgin stock may be combined with the recycled charge materials. It should be apparent that the effectiveness of recycling diminishes with increased quantities of newly refined virgin stock. Typically, the virgin stock is between 10-90% of the charge material precursor.

Since the charge materials from the recycling stream have typically endured a number of charging cycles, the recycling stream materials have ions resulting from previous charge cycles. The charge material precursor results in a cumulative pore volume based on the ions from the recycling stream. The active cathode material results from sintering the charge material precursor with lithium carbonate or similar sintering compound to form the active charge material.

TABLE I Discharge Rate Metric Recycled Material Control Material 1 C mAh/g 129.6 130.9 2 C mAh/g 120.8 119.4 5 C mAh/g 76.2 40.4

Ions enter from recycled medium and tend to settle on the surface, resulting in increased pore volume. The cumulative pore volume is increased based on ions on the surface of the particles from an agitated mass of raw materials in the recycling stream. Increased discharge rates result from the recycled materials, as shown in TABLE I, particularly at higher current draws such as 5 C. In one example, the charge material precursor results in a charge capacity of 150-160 mAh/gm at a discharge rate of 0.1 C. The recycled materials indicates the measured charge capacity at the respective C-rates, and the control material indicates testing of conventional or virgin charge materials.

The charge material precursor results in a charge capacity of between 129.6-150 mAh/gm for supporting a discharge rate of 1.0 C. At an opposite end of the spectrum, a charge capacity of between 76.2-120-8 mAh/gm was observed for supporting a discharge rate of 5.0 C.

The same tests indicate that the charge material precursor results in a cumulative pore volume of between 0.000120-0.000160 c{circumflex over ( )}3/g, with some samples resulting in a cumulative pore volume of 0.000163 c{circumflex over ( )}3/g. The charge material precursor is defined by particles having an average pore diameter of between 20.0-20.833 A.

In the example configurations, the recycled battery chemistry is nickel, manganese, cobalt (NMC), however other chemistries such as the Al based charge material above. Typical molar ratios include one of equal proportions of Ni, Mn, Co; 50% Ni, 30% Mn, 20% Co; 60% Ni, 20% Mn, 20% Co; or 80% Ni, 10% Mn, 10% Co, however any suitable ratio may be employed.

Still further, other configurations seek to improve the purity of the resulting charge material. Impurities in the charge material that deviate from the prescribed battery chemistry (i.e. NMC 111, 811, 532) negatively affect the charge capacity and discharge performance. Particularly when working with recycled battery materials, byproducts and ancillary materials result from aspects such as current collectors, casing, separators, electrical contacts, and other manufactured elements used in producing the previous generation of the functional battery are present in the recycling stream. In particular, aluminum and copper sheets are frequently used in cathode and anode current collectors, respectively. Manganese (Mn) and iron (Fe) are often employed in the physical casing and construction of the previous battery, such as for electrical contacts.

Since battery materials contain mixed oxidation state transition metals Ni²⁺, Ni³⁺, Co²⁺, Co³⁺ etc., reductive leaching has been shown to increase the effectivity of the leach. Previous applications depict synthesizing NixMnyCoz(OH)₂ (x+y+z=1), generally referred to as a precursor NMC(OH)₂), from recycled batteries. Recycling processes using an acid leach as disclosed herein takes note of the oxidation state of the metal ions defining the NMC charge material (Ni, Mn, Co or other metal ions). Reductive leaching is beneficial here as well. In this case not only does the reducing agent assist in getting the desired metal ions into solution but it also affects the coprecipitation of NMC(OH)₂. Although Ni²⁺ and Co²⁺ are the steady state oxidation states in aqueous solution, Co³⁺ can be leached into solution under certain conditions. By maintaining the metal ions of the charge material in a particular oxidation state, purity of the resulting precursor can achieve 99.5% purity, as expected for recycled charge material stock.

In general, a reducing agent (also called a reductant, reducer, or electron donor) is an element or compound that loses or “donates” an electron to an electron recipient (called the oxidizing agent, oxidant, or oxidizer) in a redox chemical reaction. The reducer's oxidation state increases while the oxidizer's decreases; this is expressed by saying that reducers “undergo oxidation” and “are oxidized” while oxidizers “undergo reduction” and “are reduced”.

In a particular example, Co³⁺ can be leached into solution at a rate of 1 mg/hr with sulfuric acid at 25° C. Thus given a particular reducing environment Co²+ will leach into solution vs Co³|+. Co²+ have a 99% leaching effectivity after 1 hr at 60° C. with H₂O₂ as the reducing agent. In the examples herein, it benefits the recycling process if the metal ions are in the 2+ oxidation state, as the +3 ions will precipitate at a different pH vs 2+ ions. Since the pH window to make desirable material can be as tight as <0.05 for a given NMC composition, the presence of 3+ ions in solution present difficulties towards generating dense spherical particles with tight control of the size.

A further enhancement to the NMC recycling approach discussed above includes adding a reducing agent to the leaching process to maintain the oxidation states. In the recycling stream of exhausted secondary batteries, the method of recycling charge materials from the batteries for use in production of recycled batteries further includes receiving a granular mass from a recycling stream based on dismantled batteries, such that the recycling stream includes a plurality of charge materials defined by a battery chemistry of the dismantled batteries. Each charge material of the plurality of charge materials is defined by a metal (such as Ni, Mn or Co) and having an oxidation state, such that the battery chemistry defining a ratio of the charge materials for inclusion in a recycled battery. The leach acid is added to the granular mass for reducing a pH of the leach solution to dissolve the charge materials in a leach solution, such that the leach acid selected based on an oxidation state of metal ions defining the dissolved charge materials in the leach solution. Depending on the charge material ratios of the incoming stream and the intended recycled battery chemistry, a ratio adjustment of the charge materials may be performed for achieving a predetermined molar ratio of the charge materials in the leach solution. Once the proper charge material ratio is attained though addition of virgin stock, a strong base is added to the leach solution for raising the pH to precipitate a granular form of compounds of the charge materials, and preferably only the charge materials, such that the granular form defines a charge material precursor responsive to sintering to form the recycled batteries.

In the examples above, the NiMnCo(OH)2 battery precursor is made from a solution of Ni, Mn and Co generated from battery waste/scrap, where the oxidation state of Ni, Mn and Co is 2+ prior to the precipitation of the battery precursor. Because the different oxidation states have a different solubility constant (ksp), Ni ions in the leaching solution should all be of one oxidation state, likewise the Co must all be of one oxidation state and the same with Mn. Ideally, reaction conditions are tightly controlled in order to make dense spherical particles that are required for the recycled battery.

The ratio adjustment includes sampling a molar ratio of the charge materials in the leach solution. If the molar ratio is different than the predetermined molar ratio for the recycled battery, additional charge materials may be added for achieving the predetermined molar ratio of the charge materials dissolved in the leach solution. The additional charge materials are selected based on a compound corresponding to the leach acid, such as sulfate forms if the leach acid is sulfuric acid. Additional materials are typically newly sourced virgin forms, such as nickel sulfate, manganese sulfate or cobalt sulfate in the example shown.

A higher purity is produced when the oxidation state of each of the metal ions in the leach solution is equal to the others of the metal ions in the leach solution. Since Ni³+ has a different ksp vs Ni²+, it may not be a viable approach to make battery grade precursors using solutions with mixed Ni oxidation states. Similarly, since Co³+ has a different ksp vs Co²+, and since Mn³+ or Mn⁴+ has a different ksp vs Mn²+, the purity may be compromised. Accordingly, it is preferable if the oxidation state of each of the metal ions defining the charge materials is 2+, resulting from adding a reductant to the leach solution for achieving an oxidation state of 2+ for the charge materials in the leach solution.

In general, the reductant is selected based on a solubility constant (ksp) of the reductant in combination with the charge materials. Hydrogen peroxide has been shown to be a viable reductant in the examples above. Other reductants include, hypophosphorous acid, sodium hypophosphite, phosphorous acid, hydrogen sulfide, sodium bisulfide, sodium sulfide, sodium bisulfite, sodium sulfite, sodium dithionite, sodium thiosulfate, hydrazine, carbon monoxide, nitric oxide and sulfur dioxide.

Similarly, the leach acid may include at least one of sulfuric acid, nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, phosphoric acid, boric acid, hydrofluoric acid, hydrobromic acid, perchloric acid, and hydroiodic acid. For example, a sulfuric acid leach with ratio adjustment using corresponding sulfate forms of Ni, Mn and Co provides effective ratio adjustment.

In addition to maintaining oxidation states of the metal ions in the leach solution, the reductant may also be selected to facilitate impurity removal. Adjustment of pH along with careful selection of the reducing agent allows precipitation of impurities while leaving the charge material ions in solution for later precipitation, thus effectively separating impurities from the recycled stock. Preferably, selecting the leach acid and adjusting of the pH is based on the solubility constant for forming a spherical particle of the precipitated charge materials. Impurity removal may occur at different stages, but often follows the addition of the leach acid. Adjustment of the pH of the leach solution is done for precipitating impurities in the leach solution resulting from the recycling stream, while leaving the charge materials in a solution form. There is a delicate balance to keeping charge materials in solution while precipitating the impurities, typically iron, copper, aluminum and magnesium.

In some configurations, small amounts of magnesium stabilize the NMC crystalline structure. Therefore, allowing small amounts of magnesium as a doping agent are actually beneficial. Ratio adjustment may include adding a dopant having a volume less than around 1% of the charge material and selected based on a stability of a resulting crystalline structure of sintered charge material. At least a portion of the dopant may be preexisting in the leach solution based on the recycling stream, such as Mg. Mg is a common dopant for high Ni NMC. Mg sits on Li sites in the Li layer. This prevents Li/Ni mixing. Li/Ni mixing is a key problem for high Ni NMC as it reduces cycling stability, rate capability, discharge capacity, and thermal stability. Because Mg sits in the Li layer and is not electrochemically active it acts as a structure pillar for the crystal lattice. It reduces lattice variation and enhances structural reversibility. Therefore, high Ni NMC doped with Mg have been shown to have longer cycle life, higher thermal stability and better rate capability.

Ratio adjustment therefore includes identifying a percentage of the dopant in the leach solution and adding additional dopant based on a percentage of the preexisting dopant. Other dopants may be considered, such as Al, B, and Ta.

Another technique for impurity removal includes electrodeposition of copper. This includes adjusting a pH of the leach solution to a range between 0-5, inserting electrodes for electrodeposition into the leach solution, and applying a voltage between 0.5 and 2.0 v to the electrodes for electrodeposition of copper remaining in the leach solution. FIG. 9 is a Pourbaix diagram of Cu as used for impurity removal. Referring to FIG. 9 , a graph 900 of pH to electrical voltage are shown on axes 901 and 902, respectively. Cu²+ tends to be deposited in the region denoted as 905. In the recycling sequence given above, prior to the electrodeposition of copper, other impurities may be removed by adjusting the pH to a range between 3.0 and 6.5 for precipitating impurities including Fe, Al and Cu. As indicated above, a lower pH in the range of 5-7 targets Fe, and a higher pH tends to precipitate Cu, as a complement or alternative to electrodeposition.

While the system and methods defined herein have been particularly shown and described with references to embodiments thereof, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and details may be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention encompassed by the appended claims. 

What is claimed is:
 1. A method for obtaining electrode material precursor with a selected ratio of metals from recycled lithium ion batteries, comprising leaching electrode materials of the recycled lithium ion batteries to obtain a solution including metals, each having a respective concentration; adjusting the concentrations of the metals with additional metal salts; and raising a pH of the solution to co-precipitate the metals at the selected ratio while maintaining the solution below 80° C.
 2. The method of claim 1, wherein maintaining the solution below 80° C. includes maintaining a structure of the co-precipitated metals.
 3. The method of claim 1, wherein raising the pH of the solution to co-precipitate the metals includes maintaining the metals commingled in the solution during precipitation. 